Gary's Restaurant, Pleasantville, NJ | Menu

Welcome to Gary's Restaurant in Pleasantville

Located conveniently at 831 N New Rd #1340, Pleasantville, NJ 08232, Gary's Restaurant stands as a welcoming destination for those seeking a genuine dining experience. Our establishment is built on the foundation of providing a comfortable space where community members and visitors alike can gather to enjoy well-prepared meals. We believe that the essence of a great restaurant lies in the balance between a warm atmosphere and consistent quality, ensuring that every guest feels right at home from the moment they walk through our doors.

At Gary's Restaurant, we focus on the fundamentals of hospitality. Our team is dedicated to maintaining a clean, friendly, and efficient environment that caters to the needs of our local patrons. Whether you are stopping by for a quick bite during a busy workday or settling in for a relaxed meal with friends and family, our goal is to provide a reliable dining option that reflects the spirit of Pleasantville. We take pride in our location and strive to be a staple in the neighborhood, offering a space where the focus remains on the quality of the experience and the satisfaction of our guests.

What Makes Us Special

Commitment to Quality: We prioritize the use of fresh ingredients and careful preparation methods to ensure that every dish served meets our standards of excellence. Our kitchen team works diligently to maintain consistency, ensuring that your favorite meals taste just as good every time you visit.
Welcoming Atmosphere: Our dining room is designed to be inclusive and comfortable, making it an ideal setting for various occasions. From casual lunches to quiet dinners, the environment is crafted to help you unwind and enjoy your time away from the stresses of daily life.
Community Focus: Being situated in the heart of Pleasantville, we value our relationship with the local community. We are proud to serve our neighbors and are constantly looking for ways to improve our service to better meet the expectations of those who support us.
Attentive Service: Our staff is trained to provide friendly and professional assistance, ensuring that your visit is smooth and enjoyable. We believe that great service is just as important as the food itself, and we strive to make every interaction positive and helpful.

The philosophy at Gary's Restaurant is simple: treat every guest with respect, serve food that we are proud of, and maintain a space that brings people together. We understand that in today's fast-paced world, finding a place that feels authentic and grounded can be a challenge. That is why we remain committed to our core values, focusing on the details that matter most to our diners. We invite you to visit us at our New Road location to see for yourself why so many locals consider us a preferred choice for their dining needs.

As we continue to grow and serve the Pleasantville area, we remain grateful for the ongoing support of our patrons. Your feedback and loyalty inspire us to keep refining our approach and maintaining the high standards that define Gary's Restaurant. We look forward to welcoming you soon, whether you are a regular face or a first-time visitor. Come experience the hospitality and dedication that we pour into everything we do, and let us make your next meal a memorable one.

Thank you for considering Gary's Restaurant for your dining plans. We are located at 831 N New Rd #1340, Pleasantville, NJ 08232, and we are always ready to provide you with a pleasant and satisfying experience. We hope to see you soon and look forward to the opportunity to serve you with the care and attention that you deserve.

Frank Miranda

12-12-2025

My family and I were in Pleasantville and we wanted to have a good family breakfast with a dine-in diner experience. I went on TripAdvisor and Gary’s Restaurant was in the top three for the best breakfast dining. We decided to try it out. TripAdvisor was not kidding. We walked in the diner and we can see that it was a packed place but the atmosphere was phenomenal. Many pictures and colorful paintings on the world really does give you that true American dining experience. The hostess spoke Spanish too which helped my family in terms of communication. Our waitress was very nice and very helpful with our selections. We selected the breakfast platters of two eggs, pork sausage, pork bacon, and home fries as well as French Toast. The food was excellent. The quality of the pork sausages links were thick and flavorful and had a nice crisp. Pork bacon not too crispy not too soft, it was good. The highlight was the home fries. The home fries came with onions and peppers and they were filled with flavor and the quality was like a nice grilled mash potatoes. My family and I loved the food so much that we ate everything. Thank you Gary restaurant and the staff for the best dining experience we’ve had in a long time. The home fries were the best! My family and I love it so much. We would definitely come back again to try the Wednesday lunch specials. To us Gary’s restaurant is number one in Pleasantville for the true American Breakfast Diner Experience. Would recommend.Meal typeBreakfastPrice per personUSD 10–20Food: 5Service: 5Atmosphere: 5Wait timeNo waitSeating typeIndoor dining areaParking spacePlenty of parkingParking optionsFree parking lot

Susan Huaccamayta

01-08-2025

Very clean, great service, yummy food. Wish portions were a bit more for the price but not bad at all, maybe I’m just being greedy lol will return. Loved the 80’s music. Hubby loved it, it was his first time having Vietnamese food.Meal typeDinnerPrice per personUSD 20–30Food: 4Service: 5Atmosphere: 5Special eventsNo special eventWait timeNo wait

Majestic Capricorn

07-05-2025

Listen…this food is so good. The shrimp and grits are amazing! The grits were flavorful & without lumps. The flash-fried cornbread had a light crisp with a sweet, cake-like taste. Everyone in my party enjoyed their food!Food: 5Service: 5Atmosphere: 5

Space